For seven seasons, fans of FOX (and now ABC's) hit procedural drama 9-1-1 have watched Evan "Buck" Buckley navigate personal growth, professional challenges, and a complicated love life. From his early days as a charming, impulsive womanizer to his more recent, introspective self-discovery, Buck's journey has been nothing short of a rollercoaster. But perhaps no development has sparked as much conversation, speculation, and excitement as his recent exploration of his sexuality. Has the character we thought we knew truly transformed? And what does this pivotal moment mean for one of television's most beloved first responders?
In the highly anticipated seventh season, episode four, titled 'Buck, Bothered and Bewildered', presented viewers with a narrative bombshell. For weeks, the show had subtly hinted at Buck's discomfort with Eddie Diaz's growing friendship with firefighter-turned-helicopter-pilot Tommy Kinard. This tension culminated not in a revelation about Eddie, as many "Buddie" shippers had hoped, but in a surprising, electric kiss between Buck and Tommy.
This single moment served as a catalyst, propelling Buck into an uncharted territory of self-awareness. Gone were the days of simply chasing women; this was a deeper, more profound realization about his own attractions, a facet of his identity he hadn't consciously acknowledged or explored before. It's a testament to the show's willingness to evolve its central characters, pushing them beyond their initial archetypes.
Following the significant kiss, a natural question arose among viewers: is Buck gay? The answer, as confirmed by showrunner Tim Minear in interviews, is a resounding no, Buck is not gay; he is bisexual. This distinction is crucial and reflective of a more nuanced understanding of sexuality.
Buck's journey isn't about switching from one exclusive orientation to another. Instead, it's about realizing that his capacity for love and attraction extends beyond what he previously understood. This mirrors the real-life experiences of many individuals who identify as bisexual, for whom attraction to multiple genders may manifest at different stages of life, or become undeniable after a specific experience.
The show subtly reinforced this. Buck's casual remark about "checking out a hot guy's ass" years prior, a seemingly throwaway line, retrospectively indicates that same-sex attraction wasn't entirely new to him, but perhaps something he had suppressed or simply not acted upon. His long history of heterosexual relationships, often characterized by a desire for connection that felt just out of reach, can now be re-contextualized through the lens of a broader sexual identity coming to the forefront.
'Buck's bisexuality isn't a plot twist; it's a deepening of a character who has always sought genuine connection, regardless of where that might lead him.'
The immediate aftermath of Buck's kiss with Tommy and his subsequent coming out to his closest confidantes sparked considerable debate among the fanbase. His sister, Maddie, and his best friend, Eddie Diaz, both reacted with immediate acceptance, a narrative choice that some viewers found surprisingly swift.
Maddie's response, while supportive, was seen by some as less emotionally charged than expected, given the magnitude of the revelation for her brother. However, it's worth noting that Maddie has always played a deeply empathetic, almost maternal role in Buck's life. It's plausible she always possessed an underlying intuitive understanding of his complex emotional landscape, making her acceptance feel less like a shock and more like an affirmation.
Eddie's reaction, in particular, was scrutinized. As Buck's "macho best friend," some fans anticipated a more complex, perhaps even initially awkward, response. Yet, Eddie, known for his deep loyalty and evolving open-mindedness, offered unconditional support. This might be seen as a conscious decision by the writers to portray a refreshing, uncomplicated acceptance, a departure from the often-dramatized coming-out narratives seen in other media. While some viewers wished for more "grappling" with emotions from Buck himself or more nuanced reactions from others, the show opted for a narrative path that prioritizes immediate validation and love within his chosen family.
Looking ahead, Buck still needs to come out to the rest of his found family at the 118 - including Captain Bobby Nash, Henrietta "Hen" Wilson, and Howie "Chimney" Han. Given the team's established supportive dynamics, it's highly probable these revelations will be met with similar acceptance, though the individual nuances of each interaction will undoubtedly be compelling viewing.
For years prior to his kiss with Tommy, an active corner of the 9-1-1 fandom passionately argued that Buck had been "queer-coded" - a term used to describe characters whose sexual orientation is implied through subtext, visual cues, or narrative elements without explicit confirmation. Many pointed to a series of moments throughout the seasons as evidence:
These instances, whether intentionally or not, built a foundation for Buck's later development. For many, his bisexual revelation wasn't a sudden shift, but rather a culmination of subtle hints and a character trajectory that always seemed to be heading towards a broader definition of love and identity. This long-standing subtextual engagement cultivated an ardent "Buddie" fanbase, shipping a romantic pairing between Buck and Eddie. While the Tommy kiss initially seemed to divert from this, it has only intensified the "Buddie endgame" speculation, with many believing Tommy is a "plot device" to help Buck understand his sexuality before he potentially explores feelings for Eddie.
The way Buck's bisexuality was revealed has drawn both praise and criticism. On one hand, many appreciated that the show didn't drag out the "coming out" narrative over multiple seasons, opting for a more direct, if rapid, progression. The kiss itself, occurring somewhat unexpectedly in his loft, served as a powerful turning point.
However, some viewers felt the emotional impact was slightly diluted by the immediate casual conversation that followed the kiss, suggesting that a moment of more profound internal processing or an earlier, more private realization might have resonated more deeply. The challenge for network television often lies in balancing dramatic tension with the need for broad appeal and sensitivity around significant character developments. While the show delivered a groundbreaking moment for a male character on a major network, the pacing and emotional weight of the revelation left some yearning for a more extended exploration of Buck's initial confusion or grappling with his new feelings.
Despite these critiques, 9-1-1 has contributed to an important conversation about LGBTQ+ representation. While shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer (with Willow) and Grey's Anatomy (with Callie Torres) pioneered similar storylines for female characters years ago, male characters exploring their same-sex attraction later in life, particularly in a mainstream procedural, are still less common. This makes Buck's journey particularly significant, offering a relatable narrative for many who may discover their bisexuality later in adulthood.
Evan "Buck" Buckley's journey of self-discovery is far from over. His bisexuality is now a confirmed part of his identity, opening new avenues for relationships and personal growth. Whether his future lies with Tommy Kinard, with whom he is now tentatively exploring a connection, or if the "Buddie" dream will eventually become a reality, remains to be seen. The show has established Buck as a character who gives his whole heart, who consistently seeks profound connections, and who is unafraid to evolve.
His story serves as a powerful reminder that self-discovery is a lifelong process, often unpredictable, and always worth embracing. As Buck continues to navigate his romantic life and the challenges of being a first responder in Los Angeles, fans will undoubtedly remain captivated by his authentic, courageous, and ever-evolving path.